Post
by CondorX5 » Fri Jun 21, 2013 8:56 am
Well I have owned both - the 3.0i and currently the 4.8is. If you do not want any regrets, go for the V8. My 3.0i had lots of extras, performed well and was a nice drive, but the 3.0i engine just seemed that bit underpowered for the big beast the X5 is especially when towing trailers etc. and the fuel consumption is the same as the V8.
Problem with the V8s is that they were once very pricey cars and some repairs on the Alpina based IS models can be pretty expensive if you are unlucky as there things like oil coolers and suchlike to factor in, also as they are getting on a bit now, may have had several owners by now who have not had the funds to spend on the maintenance but wanted the high performance,expensive when new, car.
Check the provenance of the V8 models very very carefully and walk away from poorly maintained. (Or worse, mo history available at all) vehicles.
I have a 4.8is, BMW AUC, one owner, only maintained at dealer, under extended warranty, and it still gives its fair share of issues- new alternator, new oil cooler, gear box leaking seal, split cv gaiters, pano roof issues, parking sensors, bluetooth module changed, etc, engine mounts, in addition to normal maintenance. Several 1000 £££££ worth there already, mostly covered by the warranty, luckily. They are not cheap cars to run and maintain albeit you might pick one up cheaply these days due to the crazy anti-V8 attitudes. There are still great single owner or enthusiast maintained vehicles out there, usually not on ebay though!
Be wary, look for history and condition, and depending on your budget, I would be looking for the 4.8is, they usually come with lots of extras as standard. Check that all the extras work before buying though!!!
Good luck!
X5 2005 Le Mans Blue 4.8is
Fully loaded but Now semi-retired!
X5 2012 Alpine White 40d MSport 21" style 215 black alloys, rear entertainment, media package, comfort seats and a load of other options.