An excellent series of posts doc426... I'd just about set my heart on buying from GapInsurance .co.uk so you had me scrabbling for their policy docs so I could re-read them with your points in mind.
I observed the following:
[quote=""doc4246""]
the insurers used by ... Frank Pickles (
http://www.gapinsurance.co.uk) are UK companies - although not really well known names...
[/quote]
The insurer of their policies is "Ageas Insurance Ltd", they were previously known as "Fortis Insurance Ltd". Whilst "Ageas" as a name clearly doesn't yet enjoy the brand recognition of "Fortis", they are one of the largest insurers in the UK. (See here:
http://www.ageas.com/en/Pages/brief.aspx and here:
http://www.ageas-uk.co.uk/)
[quote=""doc4246""]
4.
For the most part policies only pay out providing you have a successful claim on your underlying motor insurance
[/quote]
Surely by it's very nature, any Gap Insurance policy will only pay out if there's a successful claim on your underlying motor insurance?
[quote=""doc4246""]
5. This becomes interesting where say your vehicle is a total loss following theft using your vehicle's keys which have also been taken... the GAP insurance may exlcude this cover anyway - there's an intriguing exclusion regarding this even in the
http://www.gapinsurance.co.uk policy wording
[/quote]
I'm not sure I agree that their condition in relation to this is "intriguing". The policy has the following exclusion:
- Any Vehicle, which is left unattended unless all security devices and immobiliser are activated and are in full working order, (in addition all doors must be locked and keys removed from the Vehicle).
IMO this is perfectly reasonable.
[quote=""doc4246""]
conversely
http://www.car2cover.co.uk does include this cover however their insurer is a Gibralter registered company...
[/quote]
I specifically questioned cover for theft through the use of the vehicle keys (i.e. the keys being stolen), because I'd spotted that Car2Cover and other online providers make a bit of a song and dance about their policies covering it.
I'm assured that it always rests with your Motor Insurer, e.g. if they deem the claim to be valid, there isn't a Gap Insurance provider who would take an opposing view and subsequently reject the claim.
I was told that the general rule is: If your Motor Insurance pays out, the Gap Insurance pays out.
That seems like common sense to me.
[quote=""doc4246""]
I've even come across an exclusion of cover where the vehicle is left continuously unattended for more than 7 days...not good if you've left the vehicle at the airport car park during a holiday...
[/quote]
Really?? That's a right dodgy exclusion. I haven't come across that one in my own research in to Gap Insurance. Where did you you see this? I'd question whether that was ever enforceable though, because I'd expect it to be covered under my motor insurance still... (
note-to-self: check car insurance terms).
[quote=""doc4246""]
6. No matter what the final invoice price you pay - some GAP insurance still limit the maximum value of the vehicle to that shown in Glass' Guide...so hopefully you've not been over sold, but with a new vehicle that is far less likely than a second hand purchase where the dealer has a profit to accomodate.
[/quote]
I agree unfortunately that's always possible with a used vehicle, but highly unlikely with a new vehicle.
GapInsurance.co.uk's policies include such a restriction. I.e. They reserve the right to re-value the vehicle at the time you bought it, via reference to Glass' Guide... If you over-paid for the vehicle, it's possible that you could get stung somewhat here. However, I'm comfortable that this won't affect me.
[quote=""doc4246""]
Another exlcusion is if the total loss occurs outside the covered countries...so if the car is found in Russia (thanks to the fitted tracking device or telematics system) and is considered a total loss (burnt out or materially damaged beyond economical repair...parts removed etc) then you'll get no payout...now this is a debateable matter as to where the event actually occurred...but for a big claim, any opportunity to wriggle out is highly likely...
[/quote]
I think this unlikely to ever be an issue. If the vehicle was unlawfully taken from you, whilst you (and/or the vehicle) were within the territorial limits of the policy, then that is the location of the event. It matters not as to where the vehicle was subsequently located.
It'd be like the Motor Insurer claiming the date of loss was a month later than the actual date of loss, in an attempt to apply and payout to a lower market value. It wouldn't happen.
[quote=""doc4246""]
8. Civil commotion and riot in the UK exclusions - could be an issue...as are exlcuions relating to provisionally licenced drivers...not to mention excluions arising from driver intoxication etc...
[/quote]
Standard stuff, I've seen this in many vehicle-related insurance policies in my time.
[quote=""doc4246""]
A tough exclusion in this category is where the driver at the time of the incident giving rise to the claim was driving illegally (again
http://www.gapinsurance.co.uk) as this could imply that if you were even speeding or driving without due care and attention and successfully prosecuted for the offence, then you'd not be covered.
[/quote]
I'm told that "Driving Illegally" would be driving in any way that contravened the Road Traffic Act.
I'm no expert in legislation, nor what "offences" would count, but I'd put money on me having difficulty claiming on my Motor Insurance, if that claim arose as a result through me having broken the law. In which case, I refer back to what I've been told... No Motor Insurance payout = No Gap Insurance payout.
Incidentally, the very same exclusion is in Honda's own Gap Insurance policy - and probably many others too.
For anyone that's interested, I also took the time to compare doc4246's specific observations of ALA.co.uk with GapInsurance.co.uk:
[quote=""doc4246""]
http://www.ala.co.uk:
1. Use a UK insurer
[/quote]
So do GapInsurance.co.uk
[quote=""doc4246""]
2. Offer up to 4 years policy period
[/quote]
So do GapInsurance.co.uk, but if you have new-for-old cover as part of your motor insurance policy, you can defer the start date of the Gap Insurance policy by up to 12 months, this would mean having their Gap Insurance policy "ignore" the first year but cover years 2, 3, 4, and 5.
[quote=""doc4246""]
3. Okay they exclude dealer fitted extras but otherwise include all manufacturer/factory fitted options
[/quote]
GapInsurance.co.uk: Covers any/all genuine manufacturer, accessories/options whether they be Dealer or Factory fitted.
[quote=""doc4246""]
4. Pay out the difference of what the underlying motor insurer settles up to the limit of the GAP insurance...therefore no Glass' Guide used
[/quote]
GapInsurance.co.uk policies allow for reference to Glass' Guide therefore the vehicle value at the time you bought it could be revalued and your claim could be adjusted, though in reality this is only really going to *possibly* be an issue with a used car. New cars are likely not to be affected by such a clause.
[quote=""doc4246""]
5. Doesn't exclude theft total loss where the vehicle's keys are used - providing the keys were stolen (theft is legally defined of course) from your house following a break in (so no pick pocketing when your jacket is hanging over a chair down the pub or at a football/cricket match etc) - but this is providing your underlying motor insurance also covers this same event - worth checking this out with your motor insurer?
[/quote]
GapInsurance.co.uk: So long as you don't leave the vehicle unattended with the keys inside, cover us unaffected - so long as the Motor Insurance policy pays out!
[quote=""doc4246""]
And no unattended for 7 days or more type exclusion...so covered if vehicle parked up at the airport when away on holiday...and is stolen/damaged as total loss
[/quote]
GapInsurance.co.uk don't have such an exclusion either. I'm still amazed at the prospect of this exclusion being present in any policy. Really, where have you seen this?
[quote=""doc4246""]
6. Glass' Guide not used as a lower limit to invoice price - so invoice price is agreed
[/quote]
Sames as No.4
[quote=""doc4246""]
7. No special conditions on duration and countries visited overseas - it simply follows whatever the underlying motor insurer provides...
[/quote]
GapInsurance.co.uk will allow for the vehicle to be used in the EC plus some other countries for up to 90 days in any 12 month period. (I don't intend to travel so this won't affect me)
[quote=""doc4246""]
8. No riot/civil commotion in the UK exclusion
[/quote]
GapInsurance.co.uk have such an exclusion.
[quote=""doc4246""]
and even covers use by provisional license holders but still has the exclusions for driving illegally/commiting a crime though...
[/quote]
GapInsurance.co.uk will cover any driver of the vehicle, provided that individual is covered to drive the vehicle under a Comprehensive Motor Insurance policy.
doc4246: after reading your explicitly detailed posts (very much appreciated I might add!) I initially thought I'd be swayed to go with ALA, but after reviewing and comparing the policies from these two companies in far more detail I'm still comfortable that Frank Pickles (GapInsurance.co.uk) is the better choice for me.
Thank you for your time in spurring me on to do this.