I recently changed my summer tires to snow tires and noticed after tightening the front right wheel to the rotor... there was a slight 'shakiness' to it.
Meaning the wheel was solidly fixed/screwed to the rotor, but it felt like the rotor itself was the piece that was unstable. I checked on all the other wheels and they were all soundly fixed onto their rotors and no shaking was experienced.
Together with a slight scratching noise I have been hearing for the last 4 months... am hoping someone out there can quickly identify the fault. Is this something that usually happens after 130,000 Kilometers?
I thought it could be a ball bearing issue... but not sure. Planning on visiting the garage before xmas in anycase.
Thanks in advance for any feedback.
Not joined yet? Register for free and enjoy features such as alerts, private messaging and viewing latest posts and topics.
Front right wheel rotor unstable
Discuss the problems with your X5 (E53).
divelab
- jason@bwchiptune
- Member
- Posts: 622
- Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 12:23 pm
- Location: hayes,middlesex,west london,ub31bb
- Contact:
Re: Front right wheel rotor unstable
Post by jason@bwchiptune » Mon Oct 04, 2010 3:51 pm
get someone to look at it now!!!!
could be the wheel bearing breaking up!!! you have be warned!!!
could be the wheel bearing breaking up!!! you have be warned!!!
PERFORMANCE TUNING REMAPS,DIAGNOSTICS,SERVICE & REPAIRS
TUNING DEALERS ACROSS THE UK
DYNO DYNAMICS ROLLING ROAD
http://www.bwchiptune.co.uk
http://www.bwautorepairs.co.uk
02085611818
TUNING DEALERS ACROSS THE UK
DYNO DYNAMICS ROLLING ROAD
http://www.bwchiptune.co.uk
http://www.bwautorepairs.co.uk
02085611818
jason@bwchiptune
Re: Front right wheel rotor unstable
Post by divelab » Mon Oct 04, 2010 4:01 pm
That serious? Will defintely investigate it further and asap.
Is it typical for wheel bearing problems to impact the shakiness of a rotor -when the car is jacked up and you feel a slight looseness/wobbling of the wheel after it is tightened onto the rotor? I thought the noise I was hearing was down to the bearing issue, but didn't realise it was also now linked to this wheel problem.
Is it typical for wheel bearing problems to impact the shakiness of a rotor -when the car is jacked up and you feel a slight looseness/wobbling of the wheel after it is tightened onto the rotor? I thought the noise I was hearing was down to the bearing issue, but didn't realise it was also now linked to this wheel problem.
Silver Sport E53 X5 2003 3.0 DAT
divelab
-
OnlineX5Sport
- Global Moderator
- Posts: 18964
- Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2010 4:09 pm
- Location: Planet X6......
Re: Front right wheel rotor unstable
Post by X5Sport » Mon Oct 04, 2010 4:10 pm
Very definitely as the wheel hub is connecting to the outer part of the wheel bearing and the car to the inner part. In the good old days you used to set the wheel bearing adjustments by tightening the hub nut all the way up whilst rotating the wheel and then back it off one flat and put a split pin in. That gave just a tiny bit of movement if you held the wheel top and bottom and 'rocked' it. At least that's the way the old Police mechanics I used to work with taught me in the 1980's. No idea if that's how it's still done, but it may be. Any excess movement and/or noise was immediately investigated to see if the bearing had gone dry and was failing. Definitely something to be looked sooner rather than later. Any marks/pitting/blueing on either the bearing track or rollers was cause to change the bearing.

X5Sport
Return to “Problems (E53 1st-gen, 2000-2006)”
Jump to
- Forum
- ↳ Forum Discussion
- ↳ New members section
- BMW X1
- ↳ General X1 Forum (F48 - 2nd gen : 2015+)
- ↳ General X1 Forum (E84 - 1st gen : 2009+)
- BMW X2
- ↳ General X2 Forum (F39 : 2018+)
- BMW X3
- ↳ General X3 Forum (G01 - 3rd gen : 2017+)
- ↳ General X3 Forum (F25 - 2nd gen : 2011+)
- ↳ General X3 Forum (E83 - 1st gen : 2003+)
- BMW X4
- ↳ General X4 Forum (F26 - 1st gen : 2014+)
- BMW X5
- ↳ General X5 Forum (G05 4th-gen, 2018+)
- ↳ General X5 Forum (F15 3rd-gen, 2014+)
- ↳ General X5 Forum (E70 2nd-gen, 2007-2013)
- ↳ General X5 Forum (E53 1st-gen, 2000-2006)
- ↳ Problems (sub-forums for all models)
- ↳ Problems (F15 3rd-gen, 2014+)
- ↳ How-To
- ↳ Problems (E70 2nd-gen, 2007-2013)
- ↳ How-To
- ↳ Problems (E53 1st-gen, 2000-2006)
- ↳ How-To
- BMW X6
- ↳ General X6 Forum (F16 2nd-gen replacement, 2014+)
- ↳ General X6 Forum (E71 - 1st gen : 2008-2015)
- ↳ Problems (sub forums for specific models)
- ↳ Problems (E71 1st-gen 2008-2014)
- ↳ How-To
- BMW X7
- ↳ General X7 Discussion (G07, 2018+)
- General
- ↳ General car-related discussion
- ↳ Gallery
- ↳ Meets/Events
- ↳ The lounge
- ↳ On the light side
- ↳ Other Marques
- ↳ Buy and sell
- Links
- ↳ Z4-Forum