Not joined yet? Register for free and enjoy features such as alerts, private messaging and viewing latest posts and topics.

GearBox rebuild

Discuss your latest mods or ideas, and anything to do with the BMW X5 (E53).
Horizon
Snr Member
Snr Member
Posts: 2599
Joined: Sun Jun 10, 2012 7:34 pm
Location: Bury Lancashire

Re: GearBox rebuild

Post by Horizon » Tue Oct 14, 2014 10:29 pm

I understand the nice idea of a mates rates option on gearbox repairs, but there are loads of clued up experienced engineers out there that have the knowledge and years of experience on these commonly used gearboxes.
Go to a dedicated Auto Gearbox specialist, go into their workshops and see exactly what day to day work they are doing. Stay away from the Indies that play with the odd box or two, and guess what the problem is with your wallet as a learning budget.
I'm an Engineer myself and have 30 odd years experience , I took mine to  a dedicated Auto box specialist for service. :)
2011 Kia Sorento KX3  2.2D 60 Plate Auto in black ( mine )
BMW E83 X3.  3.0d M Sport, 2008 in black ( now gone )
BMW E93 330i Convertible  Msport  2007.  ( Now sold )
VW Golf 2.0 TDI 140 GT 2010 ( now sold )
Now Sold 55 plate, X5, 3.0 D Sport. Silv

Smeeagain
Snr Member
Snr Member
Posts: 1860
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2010 7:14 pm

Re: GearBox rebuild

Post by Smeeagain » Tue Oct 14, 2014 10:49 pm

[quote="X5-D-Sport Salisbury"]
Lots of great replies gents - thank you.

I've driven 1600 miles since doing the towing damage at the start of this posting, and NOTHING has gotten any worse since...
What I was wondering, re the whining coming from the box, turns out that it is road speed related NOT RPM...
I was wondering if the loading on the box may have "moved" the transfer box a wee tad that's bolted on the side of the main box.... done this with a Discovery many years ago, loosened and rebolted... and the whine went away instantly...
I was pondering if the layout was similar and the gear teeth between the two boxes are a tiny bit miss-aligned since the towing strains...

Just a thought, but not been underneath to look closely yet.... but if I can get away with having the mechatronic unit rebuilt with new piston/spring bits, then it will be an easy fix.....  me hopes lol

**** an idea ****
Additionally, As a very experienced engineer - Oil / Avionics / Jet Engines / UAV's / Anti Submarine Warfare..., I was wondering at the viability of acquiring a few boxes, stripping them... with the idea of getting the necessary service tools & ponder the idea of a paying hobby rebuilding these boxes..... at sensible rates, that buy a few beers + parts,
as opposed to screwing the daylights out of the customers ???

Any ideas on this little gem ? [/quote]


Only one comment really - unless you're prepared to offer a warranty or guarantee for your work it would have to be very cheap to tempt a customer?
Last edited by Smeeagain on Tue Oct 14, 2014 10:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.

AW8
Lifer
Lifer
Posts: 3189
Joined: Fri Jul 30, 2010 6:04 pm
Location: West Sussex

Re: GearBox rebuild

Post by AW8 » Tue Oct 14, 2014 10:55 pm

That's a very generous offer

Auto box failure quite simply a bill too far for many and as some earliest cars dip well below £5k I suspect an auto failure may mean end of ownership and/or a vehicles life for many

Despite the kind offs there are some issues to consider .......

1. It's not unheard of to hear of failed repairs albeit reports aren't common. My concern is similar to above in that if so called experts can have issues then the skills and tools needed to be learned may be significant.

2. Even with kindness and good will to decent folk it will cost to source tools and a few damaged boxes to play with. It may be worth sourcing boxes destined for the scrap if not exchanged though.

3. Technical and repair manuals : I seem to recall seeing some references online in past but not on this site. Main dealers tend to swap out box for box.

4. On E53 there are 3 different boxes a GM one and two ZF units.

If I was retired &/or had some spare time and skills plus spare cash to source what was required I would happily assist. I regret I do not have an engineering background or any experience overhauling auto boxes. I also work dire hours and genuinely can't justify contributing to the cost for the kit needed.

If I still have mine when cash and time are plentiful then subject to location I can be counted in as the runner and tea boy.

Regardless of any fruition it is great to see such a kindly thought idea.

:)
Last edited by AW8 on Tue Oct 14, 2014 10:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Gone - 2002 E53 X5 4.4i Sport (Pre Facelift) Owned 2006-2016.

Site & Forum Admin Team Member.

User avatar
Steamyrotter
Snr Member
Snr Member
Posts: 1304
Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 11:06 pm

Re: GearBox rebuild

Post by Steamyrotter » Tue Oct 14, 2014 11:15 pm

As an example i have had my box apart 4 times now...
And to me that is 3 times too many!!!

There are some fundamental floors in the GM box which a lot of research has uncovered and i have hopefully addressed in mine...
Manuals are available on line if you look for them, and i have posted a link to the GM box previously.

It is OK just replacing bits, but you need certain test kit to pin point the exact failure and thence the correct course of action.
Tooling can be an issue but not insurmountable, but to make life easier you need the right tools.

then there are separate tools per box design and having to keep up to date with technology.........

Then there is the warranty and insurance side.. You will need to be covered to a great extent now in this litigation semi usa nation state we are now in.....

This thought has been expressed by others here and i don't think anything has come of it mainly due to the way things are nowadays..  People will always want to lay the blame on any small thing even if it is not coupled with the original fault

I may have started my bit off on a negative..
I have enjoyed (strangely) working on the box even though I would have preferred not to have had to in the first place.  I like to know things and to dabble.  What it actually proved to me is that they are not that bad to work on but you do need to know what you are looking for to save an awful lot of time, energy and money..
If things were meant to be easy, then I will soon complicate them....
Please note...
Anything I say is only from my personal experience and knowledge..
I don't assume to know everything, and know there is a lot I don't know..
But then I could be talking bollox.. O:-)

AW8
Lifer
Lifer
Posts: 3189
Joined: Fri Jul 30, 2010 6:04 pm
Location: West Sussex

Re: GearBox rebuild

Post by AW8 » Tue Oct 14, 2014 11:52 pm

Forget £50 per hour - east of you we pay nearer £120. I read a report of a Bmw main dealer in London charging £215
Gone - 2002 E53 X5 4.4i Sport (Pre Facelift) Owned 2006-2016.

Site & Forum Admin Team Member.

User avatar
Steamyrotter
Snr Member
Snr Member
Posts: 1304
Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 11:06 pm

Re: GearBox rebuild

Post by Steamyrotter » Wed Oct 15, 2014 12:11 am

[quote="AW8"]
Forget £50 per hour - east of you we pay nearer £120. I read a report of a Bmw main dealer in London charging £215
[/quote]

Here..  Stop trying to get his prices up....


lol

Seriously though If you have everything covered then go for it.
All my bit was just personal experience, of which i have had more than my fair share..
A lesser person would have asset stripped my X5 a long time ago....
If things were meant to be easy, then I will soon complicate them....
Please note...
Anything I say is only from my personal experience and knowledge..
I don't assume to know everything, and know there is a lot I don't know..
But then I could be talking bollox.. O:-)

Post Reply